The four Roman pastas: the differences between carbonara, gricia, amatriciana and cacio e pepe

The four Roman pastas share two ingredients, Pecorino Romano and black pepper, and what sets them apart is what you add. Cacio e pepe stops there. Gricia adds guanciale (cured pork cheek). Amatriciana is gricia with tomato, and carbonara is gricia with egg. At Virginiae, Via di Parione 41, you find all four on the menu, each with its own pasta shape: spaghetti alla carbonara, bucatini all’amatriciana, tonnarelli cacio e pepe and mezzi paccheri alla gricia.

What the four Roman pastas have in common

The base is pecorino. Pecorino Romano DOP is made with whole sheep’s milk, in Lazio, Sardinia and the province of Grosseto, and the grating kind is aged at least eight months, as the data sheet from ARSIAL (in Italian), the Lazio regional agency for agriculture, sums up. It is a salty, assertive cheese, and on its own it is enough to give a dish character.

Black pepper is the second common thread. In cacio e pepe it is the star; in the other three it accompanies.

Then there is technique, which is the same for all of them. The pecorino is added off the heat, with a little of the pasta’s cooking water, because with too much heat it seizes into lumps instead of turning creamy. None of the four uses cream, garlic or onion.

Gricia: guanciale, pecorino and pepper

Gricia is the simplest of the three pastas with guanciale, and in Roman tradition it is considered the base the others come from. Guanciale is cured pork cheek: compared with pancetta it has more fat and a stronger flavour. In the pan it is rendered until crisp outside and still soft inside, and the fat it releases, melted with the cooking water and the pecorino, is the dressing.

It is the dish that explains the others: if the gricia is well made, with guanciale that is not dry and pecorino without lumps, half the work of an amatriciana or a carbonara is already done.

At Virginiae the gricia is made with mezzi paccheri, a short pasta that catches the guanciale in every mouthful. We told its story in the article on gricia, together with that of the coda alla vaccinara (oxtail stew).

Amatriciana: gricia with tomato

Add tomato to gricia and you have amatriciana. The name comes from Amatrice, in the province of Rieti, and since 2020 the traditional amatriciana sauce has been a Traditional Speciality Guaranteed recognised by the European Union, as the Lazio region’s tourism portal recalls. The recipe published there uses spaghetti, guanciale, pecorino, tomato and a splash of white wine, with no garlic and no onion.

In Rome amatriciana became tied above all to bucatini, the long, thick pasta with a hole through the middle that holds the sauce. That is also the shape Virginiae uses. We told the story of amatriciana, from Amatrice to Rome, in April.

Compared with gricia the taste changes a good deal: the tomato brings acidity and a little sweetness, and the guanciale stays more in the background. It suits anyone who wants to recognise a familiar flavour on the first forkful.

Carbonara: gricia with egg

Instead of tomato, egg. In carbonara the egg is beaten with the pecorino and the pepper and combined with the freshly drained pasta and the guanciale off the heat: the heat of the pasta thickens it into a cream without cooking it. If the pan is too hot, the egg sets and becomes a frittata; if it is too cool, the cream stays runny.

The Virginiae menu describes it in a few words: creamy eggs, crisp guanciale, Pecorino Romano and a generous grind of black pepper. It is served with spaghetti.

Many versions of carbonara’s origin circulate and none is certain. Our article on carbonara tells two of them; here it is enough to know how to recognise it: a glossy cream that coats the pasta, no trace of dairy cream, guanciale that crunches.

Cacio e pepe: pecorino without guanciale

Cacio e pepe is the only one of the four without guanciale, and for that very reason it is the hardest. All that remains is pecorino, black pepper and cooking water, and the cream has to come from their union, without the fat of guanciale to help. The pepper is toasted in the pan before the pasta goes in; the pecorino, grated very fine, is worked with the cooking water at the right temperature. Every step is explained in the article on the technique of cacio e pepe.

At Virginiae the cacio e pepe is made with tonnarelli, fresh egg pasta with an almost square cross-section, rough enough to hold the cream.

Which of the four to order

It depends on what you are looking for. A few pointers:

  • if it is your first time in Rome and you want the best-known dish, the carbonara;
  • if you want to understand guanciale, the gricia, which has nothing covering it;
  • if you prefer a red sauce and a rounder taste, the amatriciana;
  • if you do not eat pork, the cacio e pepe, which in the recipe is the only one without guanciale.

If there are two of you, order two different pastas and taste from each other’s plate: it is the quickest way to feel the difference between gricia and carbonara, or between gricia and amatriciana.

For allergies and intolerances, the allergens for each dish are listed on the menu: ask the staff anyway before you order, because the pasta shape changes the ingredients.

Where to try all four

Virginiae is at Via di Parione 41, a few steps from Piazza Navona. The four Roman pastas are on the menu next to the other first courses and the main courses of the tradition, from saltimbocca to coda alla vaccinara. The brothers Bernardo and Daniel De Luca have run the restaurant since Christmas 2015; they took on the legacy of Virginia, the Roman cook it is named after.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between gricia and carbonara?

They share the same base: guanciale, Pecorino Romano and black pepper. Carbonara adds egg, which forms a cream with the pecorino; gricia does not, and its dressing comes from the guanciale fat melted with the cooking water.

Is carbonara made with cream?

No. The creaminess of carbonara comes from the egg and the pecorino, combined with the pasta off the heat.

Which of the four Roman pastas has no meat?

Cacio e pepe: the recipe has Pecorino Romano, black pepper and pasta, with no guanciale. For specific dietary needs always ask the staff to confirm.

To try them, book through the booking page or call +39 06 8901 7261.